Vertical tray incubators give the most eggs per square metre and per litre of water, hatching troughs are cheap and simple but use a lot of space, and upwelling jars suit species with non-adhesive eggs and short incubation. For most trout and salmon hatcheries, vertical trays are the standard choice.
The three systems in short
| System | How it works | Strong points | Weak points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vertical tray incubator | 8–16 shallow trays stacked in a cabinet; water cascades down and wells up through each egg basket. | Very high density, low water use, eggs from different batches kept apart, easy to keep dark. | Higher purchase price per unit than a trough; trays must be handled one by one. |
| Hatching trough | Long horizontal trough with egg baskets; water flows along its length. | Simple, cheap, fry can stay in the same trough after hatching. | Takes a lot of floor space and water per egg; less even flow. |
| Upwelling jar | Eggs are kept gently rolling by water rising from the bottom of a jar. | Good for very large numbers of small, non-adhesive eggs (e.g. carp, whitefish). | Eggs tumble constantly – not ideal for the long incubation of salmonids; needs careful flow control. |
When a vertical incubator makes sense
- You incubate tens of thousands of trout or salmon eggs or more per season.
- Water is limited, or must be chilled or heated – lower flow means lower energy cost.
- Floor space in the hatchery building is limited.
- You want to keep batches, strains or spawning dates separate (one tray per batch).
When a trough is still a good choice
Small farms that incubate only a few thousand eggs, or that want fry to stay in the same unit from hatching to first feeding, can do well with troughs. Many hatcheries use both: vertical incubators up to hatching or the eyed stage, then troughs or tanks for sac fry.
What to check when buying a vertical incubator
- Fit between egg basket and water tray. A tight fit forces water through the eggs instead of around them.
- Mesh size. Around 1 mm openings hold trout eggs while letting dead material and silt pass.
- Materials. Stainless steel and plastic do not corrode or leach into the water.
- Water need per cabinet. HSK cabinets need 5–7 L/min.
- Spare parts. Trays wear out; make sure spares are available for years.
See our HSK SX-100, SX-80 and SX-50 incubators for complete specifications.